Shay and Jeremiah

How We Met

So one day (while flirting in a DM on Instagram lol) I sent Jeremiah a pic of my wrist tattoo & little did I know it was also his favorite scripture. He sent me a pic back, showing it was framed on his wall & said we would get married (I’m like yeah sure lol) After that, we literally started seeing the scripture EVERYWHERE! We took it as a sign from God & decided to always keep Him first in our relationship. It was the best decision we EVER made!

Engagement Proposal Ideas in New York City

How They Asked

With the help of our amazing family & friends, Jeremiah proposed on the 29th day of the 11th month. (He’s so thoughtful, even the date aligned with the scripture!) He spent 6 months organizing the proposal, contacting all of our family and close friends.

We were on a dinner date with his parents and mine, and after dinner, we walked outside to take a group pic by the water facing the Brooklyn bridge. He made me stop walking outside of the restaurant and blindfolded me.

Proposal Ideas New York City

My birthday is in a few weeks so I thought I was getting an early birthday present lol We get to the pier by the water and when he takes my blind fold off, I see our friends and family there and some are holding lighted letters that spell our “MARRY ME”! It was the best night of my life.

Where to Propose in New York City